If you cruise, sail short-handed or race casually on a tight budget, a well built Dacron mainsail is usually the better buy. It costs less, it lasts longer in sun and flogging, and almost anyone with a sewing machine, anywhere in the world, can repair it. A laminate mainsail is worth the extra money when you race seriously and shape holding wins you places, because it keeps its designed shape far longer than any woven cloth.
That is the short answer. Here is how to work out which side of the line your sailing sits on.
What Dacron does well.
Dacron is woven polyester. The yarns cross over and under each other, which makes the cloth tough, flexible and forgiving. It handles being flaked, stuffed in a bag, flogged in a squall and left out in the sun better than any other sailcloth, and a sailmaker can patch it almost anywhere.
The trade-off is stretch. Under load the weave pulls tighter and the sail’s draft moves aft and gets deeper, which costs pointing and makes the boat heel more. A better quality Dacron slows that down a lot. That is why we name the cloth: Dimension-Polyant’s C-Breeze is a tighter weave that holds its shape noticeably better out of the box than a generic Dacron, and lasts longer doing so.
What a laminate does well.
A laminate sandwiches strong, low stretch fibres between films, so the cloth barely stretches along the directions that carry load. The sail keeps the shape the designer drew for far more of its life, which means better pointing, less heel and more speed in a breeze. For a racing boat, that shape is the whole point.
The trade-offs are just as real. Laminates are stiffer to handle and stow, they don’t like being flogged or crumpled, and over time the layers can start to separate, especially in heat and sun. They are also harder to repair on the road, and once a laminate falls victim to UV and mildew there is little to be done. If you are planning to spend time cruising near the equator, a woven sail will outperform a laminate in almost every use case. A laminate that is looked after well will hold a fast shape for several seasons; a laminate left flogging on a mooring will not.
What the price difference looks like.
As a real example, a cruising Dacron mainsail for a 35 ft boat (about 30 m²) is about A$3,700 (US$2,135) in Optimum Cruise and about A$4,800 (US$2,750) in C-Breeze. A PX film laminate mainsail for a J/99 (about 33 m²) is around A$5,700 on our racing estimator. Size for size, expect a laminate to cost roughly 40% more than a value Dacron. See what a new mainsail costs by boat length for the full table.
Choose Dacron if this sounds like you.
- You cruise, day sail or do the odd twilight race.
- The sail lives on the boom under a cover, or goes up and down a lot.
- You sail short-handed and want a sail that is easy to flake and forgiving when it flogs.
- You go offshore or to remote places, where repairs need to be simple.
- Your budget is fixed and you want the most years of use per dollar. Spend the extra on C-Breeze rather than a cheap laminate.
Choose a laminate if this sounds like you.
- You race most weekends and results matter to you.
- You sail a performance boat where the rig is set up to bend and the sail shape is tuned to it.
- You look after your sails: you flake them, keep them out of the sun and don’t leave them flogging.
- You would rather have a fast sail for four or five seasons than a slower one for ten.
One cloth to rule them all.
If you want better shape than Dacron but need woven toughness, a woven Dyneema cloth such as Hydranet sits between the two. It holds shape close to a laminate and lasts like a woven sail, which is why it is popular for offshore cruising and short-handed racing. It costs more than Dacron, so it suits sailors who will use that extra life.
Not sure which way to go?
Tell us about your boat and how you sail, and a sailmaker will help you choose. If you cruise, you can see fixed Dacron prices for your boat straight away; if you race, our estimator gives laminate and membrane prices in seconds.
